Written a few days ago on LF...seems relevant
@pointblank4445 posted:
For a long, long time I was stuck in the precision rifle: "FFP Master Race" ideology myself.
In the context of the LPVO, we need re-think some stuff. Most likely we're talking small-frame semi auto AR15 or a niche' large-frame (where hopefully we've accepted some compromises).
As I have mentioned before, the constant reticle size is indeed a very big benefit to free one's self from the battery-sucking LED technology or the lesser over-illuminated reticle feature of the others (or the dated but effective wire/fiber optic of the Razor 1-6).
While skeptical myself, in my analysis of LPVO's I tried to see if I ever had a situation where the SFP was a factor on less-than-full power where I had to do the conversion for the holds. For LPVO's that max out at 6, 8 or even 10 (like the NF 2.5-10), I have yet to encounter a scenario in active deployment, hunting, class, competition or general shooting that required such a feat.
WHEN the scenarios presented themselves for where I was on 2.5, 3, 4x or whatever, I found that I was rarely outside of my 100y zero for it to matter. Or on the rare occasion it was at distance, I was more than comfortable using target reference holds (holding on parts of the body/target) anyway rather than a reticle hold. Depending on your zero, target size and skill level...300-400y is not an issue with this method.
In the case of ranging, most LPVO's aren't offering enough detail anyways for the ultra-fine milling for precision ranging without considerable practice and skill. Given modern techniques of "hasty-milling" on known-sized targets, range finders and other tech, and just the plain 'ol Mk1 eyeball for estimation, I think this is a bit much to ask of an LPVO for the intended use and the speed, distance and style of engagement/shooting we're likely talking.
In the case of precision, long-range optics...yes FFP all day every day. You are allowed to maintain the prejudice. However, given the massive task the LPVO is expected to perform, SFP is not the handicap many perceive it...in the LPVO.