Modified because it got bent a few years ago, and after beating it back closed, it now only opens to about 16 inches. Which is perfect for what it gets used for- prying suspects arms out from underneath them when they are less than compliant.
Same deal. Pretty standard in my department to ditch the baton and just use an SL20 with a terralux LED upgrade (600 lumens) and bust-a-cap tailcap.
From gym-only experience, I think an expandable baton is only marginally better than a flashlight but not nearly as good as a wooden straight stick for creating tip speed and distance.
If I actually thought I'd be using the baton for it's intended purpose I might go with a Monadnock (the button is handier) or a Peacekeeper. But so far.... I haven't.
good ole wooden night stick. My dads stick , thing has been on the streets of NYC for well over 50yrs. between the both of us. It has a few scars from the days when we could do real police work.
Streamlight SL20 ever since switching departments and the new place not allowing my Peacekeeper baton Those Peacekeepers are awesome, the end is a solid piece of milled still vs the hollow end of an Asp. Old department issued them, oh how I miss Texas...
The weight wasn't really noticeable for me, they are pretty close. The biggest difference is how they're balanced. All the weight of the Asp is in the handle vs the Peacekeeper that has all the weight in the tip. I sent you a message, my old one is just collecting dust if you want to take it out for a test run.