I’ll give more input on the Brownell’s RMR slides. The updated version I have for the 19 Gen 4 has worked flawlessly with my small box of holsters (who am I kidding, my drawer of holsters and box of holsters that I actually use currently). The finish is fantastic, definitely better than the gen 3 and gen 4 OEM finish. I bought mine with a discount code so it was $229 with 10% off. 2-3 days later Brownells has the slide on sale in addition to the 10% off. I called and they refunded me the difference, that kind of service is why Brownells will continue to get my service. FWIW, I had been trying to decide between this option and buying a new stock 19 to send off to ATEI or Jagerwerks. The thing that made me go with the Brownell’s slide (aside from it being WAYYYYYY cheaper) was the fact that the slide would be covered by Brownell’s unconditional lifetime guarantee. If I ever have an issue with it they’re going to help me out. I was stupid enough to forget Loctite on one of the screws and lost it on the first range session. Called them and they sent me two new screws free. The fitment of the slide to the front of the RMR is tight and the threads for the mounting screws rise above the surface of the slide to meet the underside of the RMR. I’m not about to torture test the slide, but I have not had to adjust zero yet so I’m satisfied so far. I am running the slide with a Faxon match barrel. It was tight at first but I have not had any malfunctions with this combo that were not blatantly user-induced or ammo induced. The Trijicon HD suppressor height sights on this slide are just barely taller than “absolute cowitness” height. That was a deal breaker for me on the sights. I got the Trijicon HD XR sights and the dots on them just barely clear the base of the RMR. On this setup they have been relegated to being true backups.